Brother's Pizza

Serving the area for over 40 years!

Our Story

Our Story

Brother's Pizza

Highland Falls, NY

Established in 1974, Brother's Pizza first opened its doors in Highland Falls, NY, where we quickly established a reputation as one of the best pizzerias in town. Brother's is known for the quality of its products and customer service, which has led it to become a benchmark in the local community. Family owned and operated, we pride ourselves on serving traditional, homemade thin-crust pizza prepared with only fresh ingredients.

We choose only to use only superior ingredients. We make our own dough fresh daily and we throw the dough by hand to keep it soft. Our sauce contains a selection of herbs and tomatoes which gives our pizzas a special flavor. We use a blend of authentic mozzarella cheeses with a tender, rich profile that give a distinct classic pizza taste. And we use only freshly cut premium meats and vegetables for our toppings, which we spread amply on every pizza. All this adds up to the quality you expect from Brother's Pizza.

This commitment to quality and authenticity is what brings our customers back again and again, whether they choose to dine in or carry out. It's the finer details that make all the difference between something you like and something that's your favorite. And your favorite pizzeria is what we intend on being.

It's a privilege serving our loyal customers for over 40 years. Come in and begin a tradition with us, and enjoy any of our pizzas, sandwiches, calzones or salads! There's no one else with the freshness and flavors you'll always find at the best place for pizza: Brother's Pizza.

Our Menu

Our menu features all of your favorite foods, including thin-crust and sicilian pizzas, salads, hot and cold sandwiches, and calzones. And of course, everything has that delicious Brother's taste.

Click Here

Stop In for Lunch or Dinner!

Dine In or Take Out

No Delivery

Visit us at our location on 233 Main Street, Highland Falls, NY 10928


Mondays - Fridays 11AM to 8PM

Saturdays 12PM to 8PM

Closed Sundays

We Accept Debit & Credit Cards - VISA/MasterCard

A 3.5% Non Cash Adjustment (NCA) is applied to all Card Transactions

(845) 446-4988